JOHN KEEL NOT AN AUTHORITY ON ANYTHING

John apparently sent Ivan Sanderson a report on his meeting with Lt. Col. Maston Jacks.  I haven’t found a copy in John’s papers; but here’s Sanderson’s response to it, on April 29, 1966.  Sanderson also included a couple of clippings: one about a UFO sighting in Oklahoma City, on July 31, 1965; and one in which the astronomer Sir Bernard Lovell dismissed UFOs as “incredible nonsense.”

I’m also posting a copy of Jacks’s response to John’s letter of inquiry.  Obviously, he just wanted to give John a copy of “Project Blue Book” and make jokes about little green girls.  John found that an association with Playboy wasn’t necessarily helpful.

The correspondence continues, in a long and lively letter from Ivan Sanderson, on April 22, 1966.  He expresses his impatience with the lists of reports found in many UFO publications, and the paucity of interpretation; and dwells on some of Kenneth Arnold’s oddities, speculating that he may have been spreading disinformation.  He also enclosed a copy (quite faded now) of a letter from the unnamed “philosopher,” offering a mostly positive critique of his recent UFO talk.

I apologize in advance for Sanderson’s racist remarks in the second paragraph.  They do crop up in his letters.  I don’t condone them, but prefer to give you the letter uncensored; the rest of it is worth reading.

John was born on March 25, 1930.  He would have been 83 today; here he is when he was younger.

Meanwhile, John was preparing to beard NICAP in its den, and to see if he could dig up anything from the military.  He was also working on his ill-fated UFO piece for Playboy; the research was apparently destined for both the article and the book.

He visited Ivan Sanderson and his wife Alma to discuss the project.  John liked to reminisce about his visits to Sanderson’s farm, particularly the fact that a playful baby elephant was once in residence, and delighted in goosing visitors.  This bread-and-butter letter was written on April 12, 1966.

After the last exchange of letters, Ivan Sanderson fired off a short note to John, full of enthusiasm for the subject and for the proposed book.  He also attached a 16-page talk he had given to a local UFO group.  The title (if you’re curious) is “Notes on a New Concept: This may be described as a General Biological Field Theory of a cosmic nature.”  Vintage Sanderson!

Two days later, he responded to the criticisms that John had written to their agent, Ollie Swan.  He puts up a lively defense; and points out his years of experience in writing and speaking for the public.  There’s also an interesting bit in there about the “worrying matter of Forteanism.”  He also attached a few pages on the different kinds of ufologists, and a transcript of the Q. & A. from his talk to the UFO group.  (I haven’t included the attachments, since they’re long and faint carbons).

Sanderson wrote to his agent, Oliver Swan, on April 12, 1966, filling him in on the proposed UFO book.  He gave his reasons for the title, and discussed his working relationship with Keel.  I should mention that, in fact, John didn’t have a commission from Playboy to write the definitive UFO article; he had agreed to a short article on spec.  Also, he didn’t write regularly for the magazine, but had only been published in the letters column.

On April 15, John also wrote to Swan.  There was trouble brewing: he was already balking at Sanderson’s chatty style.  John was an American journalist, and Sanderson a Scottish raconteur; and they had very different approaches to their material and to their audience.  Ideally, they should have complemented one another, but ideals don’t always materialize.

I posted something a while ago on the book that John Keel and Ivan Sanderson tried to write together in 1966.  It was to be called Abominable Space Things, and was to cover the subject of UFOS from early history to the present (well, to 1966, that is).

In the next few posts, I’ll air some of the correspondence from that failed collaboration.  As you’ll see, they had different approaches and strong personalities, and the project fizzled.  This first letter is from Sanderson to Keel, April 12, 1966.  He’s evaluating some of their sources, assessing the commercial possibilities of the book, and figuring out representation.  More will follow…

In 1967, Jaye Paro put John in contact with Mr. Apol, or Appell, a supposed ultraterrestrial. John exchanged several letters with him; I posted one of them a while ago, here.

John also sent him a series of questionnaires, which he filled out with his customary red pencil. There were five of them; I’ll post the second, only because the pencil is darker on this one.

All of John’s contact with Apol was through Paro; as far as I can tell, she was channeling him. Apol’s answers are interesting; but John’s questions intrigue me more: these are the things that he wanted to know. He clearly valued the correspondence at the time, and believed he was getting valuable information. But, of course, these damned ultraterrestrials, whether imaginary or not, are not to be trusted…

John’s foray into mail order and ad sheets in the ’80s puzzled many Keel-watchers. However, his articles weren’t selling, and his attempts at novels and plays were no more successful. The ad sheets were a way to have a little harmless fun, and maybe pick up a few bucks. He put out nine issues of the Big Apple News, from 1984 to 1986.  It was usually a two-sided sheet, although a couple were four pages. It contained small ads, usually for other ad sheets, John’s own ads, and a sprinkling of cartoons and clippings. Here are some representative samples; the article on snakes was one he did for High Times in 1980.

Well, this is a curious thing. In the same little plastic box with the wooden plugs from a telephone in Point Pleasant, John kept this pill. And he had this to say about it, in his unfinished dictionary:

In fact, sulfa or sulpha is a common antimicrobial, and the most popular antibiotic before the discovery of penicillin. Roche still produces it. The idea that aliens might want to protect themselves from microbes recalls, inevitably, The War of the Worlds, in which microbes were the downfall of those nasty Martians.

Several of John’s “silent contactees” (UFO experiencers who shunned publicity) reported that aliens and/or Men In Black took pills. I suppose this one was given to John by one of them. (ADDENDUM: It was given to him by Jaye Paro, one of the contactees he was investigating, in 1967.)

I’ll point out that John doesn’t seem to have had direct contact with anyone claiming to be an alien; phone conversations and correspondence were always through the contactees, sometimes by channeling. To me, that suggests that the supposed UTs (ultraterrestrials) had no independent existence. But, for all of us intrigued by those persistent tales of pill-popping aliens, well, this is what the pills looked like.